Blog

Questions about beds and mattresses answered. And some stories told.

Buying a mattress is a big decision—after all, it directly impacts your sleep quality and overall health. With so many options available, it’s easy to feel overwhelmed the moment you step into a mattress store. A common question arises: How many mattresses should you try before it all starts to blur together?

In this post, we’ll break down how many mattresses you should realistically test, share tips to make the shopping experience more effective, and explain how to avoid decision fatigue.

Why Testing Mattresses in Store Is Very Much Worth It

Online reviews and specs can be somewhat helpful, but nothing replaces the experience of actually lying on a mattress. In-store testing lets you feel the firmness, support, and responsiveness of different mattresses—something that can vary significantly based on your body type and preferred sleeping position.

So, How Many Mattresses Should You Try?

Experts generally recommend trying three to four mattresses during your visit. Here’s why:

• Fewer than three might not give you enough variety to find what suits you best.
• More than four can lead to information overload, where the differences between mattresses start to blur.

After testing several in a row, your brain struggles to distinguish subtle variations in comfort and support. That’s when decision fatigue can set in.

Signs You’ve Tried Too Many Mattresses

If you notice any of the following, it’s probably time to pause:

• You feel overwhelmed or mentally drained
• You can’t remember which one felt best
• All the mattresses start to feel the same
• You’re feeling indecisive or frustrated

When this happens, step back, take a break, or refocus on your top picks.

Tips for Testing Mattresses Without Getting Confused

Here’s how to get the most out of your store visit:

1. Limit Yourself to 3–4 Mattresses
   Choose a mix of firmness levels and materials to get a meaningful comparison.
2. Spend 5-10 Minutes on Each
3. Lie in your normal sleeping position to assess real-world comfort and support.
4. Take Notes or Use a Comparison App
   Keep track of your thoughts so you don’t rely on memory alone.
5. Dress Comfortably and Bring Your Own Pillow
   Wearing relaxed clothing and using your regular pillow can make the experience more realistic.
6. Ask Questions
   Talk to sales staff about construction, warranties, trial periods, they’re there to help.

Why Too Many Options Lead to Decision Fatigue

When faced with too many choices, your brain has to work harder to make decisions. This mental strain—called decision fatigue—can make it harder to choose or even lead to regrettable decisions. Focusing on a few thoughtfully chosen options reduces this stress and helps you make a confident, informed purchase.

Final Takeaway: Choose Quality, Not Quantity

You don’t need to try every mattress in the store. Instead, focus on a small, diverse set of high-quality options and spend time evaluating each one carefully. Taking a deliberate approach—rather than rushing through dozens—leads to better outcomes and less confusion.

Remember, a good mattress is an investment in your well-being. It’s worth slowing down and getting it right.